Bleach (sodium hypochlorite) is what most exterior cleaners use, and it works. These are the reasons we switched, with the exact words from the people who wrote them — poison centers, NIOSH, the Chlorine Institute, roofing manufacturers, and Florida and California cities. Every line links to the original document.
"This pesticide is toxic to fish and aquatic organisms." "Do not discharge effluent containing this product into lakes, streams, ponds, estuaries, oceans or waters."
"DANGER: Corrosive. Causes irreversible eye damage and skin burns. Harmful if swallowed, inhaled, or absorbed through skin."
"As a general rule, do not allow metals (except for titanium and tantalum) to come in contact with sodium hypochlorite." "Virtually all common metals such as mild steel, stainless steel and Hastalloys will corrode rapidly."
Bleach <20%: duplex stainless "B", Buna-N "not recommended." Hydrogen peroxide <30%: duplex stainless "A."
"Cleaning chemicals are highly corrosive and can easily damage diaphragm pumps." — "Sodium Hypochlorite is extremely corrosive. It will slowly deteriorate the inside of your pump as it passes through."
"Chlorine bleach can be harmful to landscape plants." "Do not allow the solution to dry on the plants, wash it off immediately."
"Prior to applying the solution, all ground vegetation directly under the roof should be covered."
"The effectiveness of such cleaning is only temporary, and the discoloration may recur." "DO NOT use a power washer."
"Water dilutes SH but does not neutralize it." … "the lingering chemical that causes leaf burn hours after you leave the property."
Bleach solutions — Aluminum: "D: Not recommended." Buna rubber: "D."
"Dermal exposure often leads to ingestion because animals will self-groom and lick the bleach off." "Concentrated or 'ultra' bleaches may be corrosive (cause chemical burns)." — "Ingestion of undiluted bleach can cause injury to the mouth and esophagus."
2022: "2,064,875 human exposures"; top categories "analgesics (11.5%), household cleaning substances (7.23%)." Among children under 6, bleach was 24.7% of all cleaning-product calls — the largest single product.
NIOSH REL: "C 0.5 ppm [15-minute]." Symptoms: "Burning of eyes, nose, mouth… cough, choking… pulmonary edema."
New-onset asthma associated with "bleach/quaternary compounds (OR, 1.91)." Respiratory symptoms in cleaners "associated with… chlorine bleach."
"409 cases of chlorine exposure in 1990 from acid mixtures with hypochlorite"; "128 required treatment in health-care facilities."
"At 95 °F / 35 °C the half-life is 48 days." … "a product made at 12.5% available chlorine will have decomposed to circa 10% within a week."
"Extensive oxygen buildup can cause a tank to rupture if left unchecked and unmitigated." "bleach solutions are best kept at temperatures beneath 60°F (15°C)."
"No pollutants of any kind, including wash water from power washing activities may be discharged" … "fined up to $5,000 per day."
Lee County: "The discharge of any pollutant into a waterway, or a system connected to that waterway, is called an illicit discharge." Naples: prohibited discharges include "process wastewater, and wash water." Estero: violators pay "a fine to cover administrative and remediation costs."
"Never drain chlorinated water to the street or stormdrain." "Violators of the stormwater ordinance may be fined up to $10,000 per day." — "Even at low levels, chlorine can be toxic to aquatic life."
"discharge of a roof de-mossing mixture containing bleach into Reay Creek" … "administrative penalty of $11,000."
"It is illegal to discharge polluted wash water from pressure washing" … "up to $10,000 per day per incident." Sacramento: avoid cleaners with "hydrofluoric acid, muriatic acid, sodium hydroxide, bleach, etc."
These rules cover all wash water, ours included. The difference is what's in it when it gets there.
Peroxy compounds "degrade rapidly in air to form oxygen and water." "Readily biodegradable (i.e., < 10 days)."
"Less than 8% concentration H2O2 is considered a non-hazardous substance." (The 35% concentrate is a corrosive oxidizer and is handled like one.)
"Risks to wildlife are considered minimal." — "Hydrogen peroxide breaks down rapidly in water." "Hydrogen peroxide does not accumulate in the food chain."
USDA organic rule, 7 CFR 205.601: "Hydrogen peroxide." USDA review: "There are no known cases of hydrogen peroxide causing environmental contamination." FDA, 21 CFR 178.1010: "An aqueous solution of hydrogen peroxide … may be used on food-contact surfaces in public eating places."
"safe for use around kids and pets (51%)"; "made with non-toxic or chemical free ingredients (41%)."